Why We Bought ItDurabilityPerformance and Fuel EconomyRetained ValueSumming UpInside Line spent the past year with the 2007 Toyota Tundra SR5, Toyota's new entry into the full-size truck segment. The centerpiece of a bold new initiative in the truck market with a brand-new assembly plant in San Antonio, the Tundra has left behind its compact dimensions of the past and embraced life as a full-size American pickup. It earns the right to be called a real truck with its hard-working capability, but in doing so it alienates buyers seeking a truck for casual use.
Why We Bought ItThe 2007 Toyota Tundra is more than an all-new Tundra; it's an all-new truck concept for Toyota, a full-scale work truck. With a payload capacity of nearly 1,600 pounds and a towing capacity of over 10,000 pounds, the Tundra means business. Toyota backed up this truck's utility with a 5.7-liter V8 generating 381 horsepower and 401 pound-feet of torque. These figures alone were enough to secure its place in our garage. But there was more.
We had already completed a
full test of the 2007 Toyota Tundra Limited with impressive results. And a Tundra Double Cab 4x4 won our full-size pickup
comparison test against the
Chevrolet Silverado and
Nissan Titan. A test of the Tundra's long-term durability was the obvious next step. If this truck's reliability held true to its Toyota pedigree, the Tundra would be the truck to beat in the half-ton truck segment.
There was another factor influencing our decision to add a Tundra to the fleet. A few months earlier
we had purchased a 2007 Chevrolet Silverado LT. We looked forward to measuring the two most significantly improved trucks of the year side by side. So we ordered a Tundra with specifications similar to those of our Chevy.
DurabilityWe can sum up just how the 2007 Toyota Tundra drives in one word: big.
The Tundra's work-duty chassis and suspension also produce a rougher ride than some competitors like our Silverado 1500. Drive the Chevy and Toyota back to back and it's hard to believe they are roughly the same dimensions. The domestic truck rides smoother on the highway and feels more manageable in parking lot situations.
In tight quarters it takes considerable practice to master this truck because of limited visibility front and rear. Toyota recognizes the shortcomings of its full-size dimensions by offering front and rear parking sensors as well as an optional rearview camera. These features help minimize any advantage the Silverado might have in low-speed maneuvering.
Video Production Specialist John Adolph used the Toyota to tow his boat up to Mammoth Lakes, California, on multiple occasions. Adolph commented, "When hooking up the trailer and launching the boat, the back-up camera proved invaluable. With the boat loaded it was easy to gauge what was straight by looking over my shoulder. With the trailer empty, it was hidden from view by the tailgate. Using the camera I was able to get the ball and receiver within an inch of each other most of the time. But be warned: The camera lens isn't centered and is mounted at a slight angle. Straight back isn't really straight back, so it takes some practice."
Beyond the parking lots and boat launches of the world we found the Toyota to be more than capable. Lead Senior Editor Ed Hellwig recognized the merits of the all-new Tundra on the
long-term blog pages.
Hellwig wrote, "Say what you want about the Tundra's styling, but I can assure you that the engine is nearly flawless. As smooth as Camry's V6 and never at a loss for power, the Tundra's 5.7-liter engine is a refined beast that has no equal in the segment. Add in the nearly perfect six-speed automatic and the Tundra makes for an excellent truck whether you're towing a load or just tooling around town."
Engineering Editor Jay Kavanagh found that the 2007 Toyota Tundra is just as impressive with a trailer in tow. While towing his $500 racecar to yet another 24 Hours of LeMons, Kavanagh noted, "I packed hundreds of pounds of spare parts, tires and tools into the bed, four passengers in the cabin, and lashed a heavy steel dual-axle trailer carrying a lightweight Honda CRX to the hitch. The truck took over from there. This engine has power throughout its rev range, but the transmission really steals the show when towing. Six speeds ensure there is never a flat spot in the power delivery, providing a huge confidence boost when passing slow-moving trucks. Shifts are uncommonly smooth. And the tow-haul mode was easily up for the job, providing just the right amount of gear holding."
Inside the cabin we agree the Tundra offers a design that's perfectly functional overall. But we had mixed opinions regarding Toyota's use of space.
Those who disliked the Tundra's immense interior space cited the huge dash as one reason. Radio and navigation system controls are located about 3 inches beyond the reach of even the longest arms. Members of this camp also criticized the lack of storage under its rear seats. One editor noticed, "When you fold the rear seats up to load cargo, the space is obstructed by seat rails. Our particular truck has a subwoofer that eats up more of this space. When you contrast this with our Silverado, which has a completely unobstructed load floor, it's obvious Toyota missed this mark here."
Others appreciated the practical benefits of the huge interior. There is plenty of room to maneuver when installing a car seat on the rear bench. With the seat installed, there is even still plenty of room for an adult on either side. Large control knobs were commended for their ease of use, whether we were bare-handed or wearing gloves. And the interior storage abounds.
Prescribed service intervals for the 2007 Toyota Tundra arrive every 5,000 miles. We held closely to this schedule, and perhaps as a result experienced no mechanical problems.
Regular maintenance wasn't cheap at our local dealer, Toyota of Santa Monica, but it did solid work. Maintenance costs averaged $77 for the first two appointments and about twice that for the second two. Our test ended prior to the truck's more costly 25,000-mile service.
We put the Tundra's parking sonar to the test when we collided with a parking structure support beam, causing nearly $600 in damage to the quarter panel and rear door. The sonar worked fine; our reaction time did not. Repairs at our trusted body shop, Burke's Auto Body in Long Beach, had us back on the road in a matter of days.
Total Body Repair Costs: $588.35
Total Routine Maintenance Costs (over 12 months): $454.10
Additional Maintenance Costs: None
Warranty Repairs: None
Non-Warranty Repairs: None
Scheduled Dealer Visits: 4
Unscheduled Dealer Visits: None
Days Out of Service: 4 days to repair body damage
Breakdowns Stranding Driver: None
Performance and Fuel EconomyAs with all long-term vehicles, we track tested the Tundra at the beginning and end of its year of service. Over this time it didn't miss a beat, recording virtually identical results at 1,000 miles and 25,000 miles.
A respectable 6.9 seconds was all the 5,600-pound Tundra required to reach 60 mph from a stop. Senior Road Test Editor Josh Jacquot noted, "6.9 seconds to 60 mph in a full-size truck is impressive to say the least. This is the best transmission and engine combination in its class." We recorded a quarter-mile time of 15.1 seconds at 93 mph. These figures are strong compared to those of the 2007 Chevrolet Silverado LT (7.2 seconds to 60 mph; 15.5 seconds at 88.1 mph in the quarter-mile) and the 2007 Nissan Titan (6.7 seconds to 60 mph; 15.3 seconds at 89 mph in the quarter-mile).
The 2007 Toyota Tundra proved just as capable in the deceleration tests, as the SR5 used 140 feet to reach a stop from 60 mph. Test driver Jacquot wrote, "Man, this truck still has incredibly powerful brakes. Even after 25,000 miles. No fade." By comparison the Silverado and Titan needed 139 and 127 feet, respectively. But neither could match the consistency of the Tundra over multiple stops.
Dynamic testing isn't a selling point of full-size trucks, but we ran the Tundra through the slalom and skid pad regardless. The Toyota generated 0.71g of lateral force, nearly identical to its Chevrolet and Nissan counterparts. Some 58.2 mph was the fastest speed we were able to achieve with the SR5 in the slalom due to the intervention of its stability control (it can't be switched off) and inconsistent test surface conditions.
Fuel economy is about equal among all three of these trucks. After 12 months we averaged 15 mpg in the Tundra, with our best single tank an impressive 22 mpg.
Best Fuel Economy: 21.9 mpg
Worst Fuel Economy: 10.7 mpg
Average Fuel Economy: 15.1 mpg
Retained ValueOur Tundra had a starting MSRP of $37,219. Twelve months and more than 25,000 miles of service depreciated its value 38 percent according to
Edmunds' TMV® calculator. We attribute much of this loss in value to rising gas prices, which have taken their toll on full-size truck sales nationwide.
True Market Value at service end: $23,026
Depreciation: $14,193 or 38% depreciation from original MSRP
Final Odometer Reading: 25,630
Summing UpToyota received plenty of flak when it first entered the full-size truck scene with the two-thirds-scale T100 in 1993, and the criticism didn't stop when it was rebadged as the Tundra in 2000. It was too soft to be considered a true work truck in a segment dominated by domestics, they argued. This truck was built for the casual truck buyer, someone who needed it only to pick up a sheet of plywood from Home Depot or tow an aluminum fishing boat to the lake.
The 2007 Toyota Tundra proved itself to be very much the opposite. Toyota went for the hard-core truck buyer with this Tundra. This truck's capabilities place it midway between its half- and 3/4-ton competitors. Its 10,000-pound tow rating is incredible. A six-speed transmission is similarly remarkable for a full-size truck. Even the V8 is among the strongest in this class. At the same time, the combination of such extreme capability requires some compromises in ride quality, and this truck's large dimensions might also limit its attractiveness to the average buyer.
We found the 2007 Tundra to be highly capable during our test. There was nothing we could throw at this pickup that it couldn't handle with ease. Toyota has finally delivered what even the skeptics would agree is a real full-size truck. But it does so at the expense of the casual truck crowd.
The manufacturer provided Edmunds this vehicle for the purposes of evaluation.
Add A Comment »