Why We Bought ItHow It DroveInside the CabinSumming UpChanges to the Tacoma Since 2005Ups and DownsRecalls and Problem HistoryDealer Service ReviewsWhat Consumers SayWhy We Bought ItAlthough Toyota sold its first pickup in the U.S. in 1964, it was the fourth-generation Toyota truck that really brought the compact pickup into the mainstream. Now, the Tacoma represents about 10 percent of the company's total annual sales, and that top-selling truck was completely redesigned for 2005. Today, Toyota has a reputation for building reliable, capable trucks that are both comfortable and tough. Is that reputation well deserved? We aimed to find out by subjecting a new Tacoma Double Cab to the rigors of daily life.
With so many cab, bed and drivetrain choices available, we finally settled on a Tacoma Double Cab 4x4 with TRD Sport Package that we felt would be the perfect foil to our long-term
2005 Nissan Frontier Crew Cab 4x4 Nismo.
Our bright red Tacoma was nicely equipped, but not exactly a "fully loaded" truck. We ordered the TRD Sport Package #3 which included remote keyless entry, trip computer and cruise control — features we figured most Tacoma Double Cab buyers will want. The cost for that package was $3,345. Many of those features are standard on the Nissan Frontier — that's something to think about next time you see a TV ad touting the Tacoma's super-low base price. Total sticker price including destination was $29,730.
How It DroveWhile the Tacoma is certainly comfortable for a truck, several editors found the ride a bit choppy when the bed was empty. This is due partly to the truck's optional TRD suspension. It's not the most comfortable truck on the highway when empty but it works really well off-road and when hauling a heavy load. Recently, Road Test Editor Brian Moody took a 50-mile trip to buy some used paving stones he called a "really killer deal." You've gotta love that
Craigslist. Of the return trip he commented, "I probably had 1200 pounds in the Tacoma's bed. The suspension sagged a little but the ride was much better with the bed loaded — it's actually quite smooth. But before I could unload the truck completely, I realized I was late for one of my son's many kiddie birthday parties. I took a quick shower and drove the truck half full of paving stones to the party and the Tacoma was just as comfortable as if I had been driving a
Camry." Unfortunately, as a result of that sagging bed and a high curb, Mr. Moody busted a mud flap off the right rear of our red pickup. Although we fixed it ourselves, the replacement mud flap with accompanying fasteners and tax set us back $100. That's more than we would expect to pay for a broken mud flap.
The Tacoma's brake pedal also earned its fair share of comments. Most editors feel that its travel is too long and the linkage seems to rattle as you step off the pedal. Senior Content Editor Erin Riches noted that the transmission was also not up to Toyota standards. She said, "The automatic transmission is not as responsive on downshifts as the
Frontier's transmission." Still other editors felt the Tacoma needed a manual transmission to make the most of the V6 and some even resorted to shifting the automatic themselves.
Inside Line Executive Editor Scott Oldham summed it up by saying, "The transmission finds top gear too soon."
Another common point of contention with the Tacoma was the noisy engine. Road Test Editor Josh Jacquot noted, "Power is adequate but the engine is too loud." Others speculated that it was a noisy cooling fan. But no one complained about the power from the Tacoma's 4.0-liter V6. We had it pulling a 5000-pound trailer in the heat of Death Valley and the Toyota never balked. In a
comparison test that pitted the Tacoma against the Nissan Frontier, the Tacoma was a champ in the sand dunes, but ultimately it was the Frontier that came out on top because it was a little easier to live with every day.
The Tacoma's size was also an issue — most drivers found the Tacoma Double Cab to be too long.
Inside Line Editor in Chief Rich Homan said the truck requires a "three-point turn to dock." Brian Moody added, "I can appreciate that the Tacoma is now larger but our crew cab with a long bed takes away one of the things I've always loved about small trucks; the fact that they're small." Senior Consumer Advice Editor Phil Reed had a different take. He said, "Although the truck in actuality is not that long, the ride height and narrow rear window make it difficult to sense the perimeter. This makes me tentative when parking and I find myself wishing for a park distance-warning system." Content Editor Warren Clarke relates a similar feeling but with more tangible consequences: "I learned the hard way just how big and unwieldy the Tacoma is. I drove the truck to see a late showing of
Walk the Line. The movie was great, but my trip out of the parking structure was not. I was stuck in a long line of cars waiting to exit the building, and I was faced with navigating a very sharp right turn. Combine the narrowness of the driveway with the width and length of the Tacoma and you had a recipe for disaster. The fact that I was hemmed in both in front and back by a queue of cars didn't help matters. In the end, the Tacoma suffered a scrape on its right rear quarter, where it made contact with a column in the parking structure." Total repair cost: $600.
Inside the CabinOne thing that surfaced time and time again was the idea that the Tacoma's interior was lackluster, but ultimately comfortable and practical. Senior Editor Ed Hellwig spent four hours in the driver seat and still found it comfortable. Up in the foothills of the Sierra Nevada Mountains, Production Editor Caroline Pardilla said the Tacoma "was able to swallow up four people and four days' worth of camping gear and food, and still deliver a comfortable five-hour ride." Rich Homan summed it up best with this quote from the logbook: "This is a classic Toyota: well made, killer quality...."
There's no question that our Tacoma was well-built but like Rich said, it just didn't seem special; it could have been the gray interior. Even so, all the various surfaces and textures are brought together in a top-quality fashion. The gauges are straightforward, the controls are easy to use and the Tacoma Double Cab's interior could easily carry a family of five. A real high point inside is the Tacoma's abundant storage space. With storage areas under the rear seats and various compartments throughout the cab, road trips are a breeze.
Up front there's plenty of headroom, but rear legroom is slightly lacking for adults.
Summing UpThe bottom line is that the Toyota Tacoma is a real truck, with all the benefits and drawbacks that brings. When the bed is empty the ride seems choppy, but its ability to haul stuff is almost limitless (for its size). As a daily driver, the Tacoma would be a little easier to live with without the TRD suspension. But if you go off-road or plan on loading the bed up to near capacity, that package could be worth the extra money.
The cabin may not be much to look at, but it's ultimately comfortable, functional and well built. When configured as a Double Cab like our test truck, the Tacoma offers the versatility of a pickup with the comfort of a small sedan. A family of five should be able to fit without much hassle, but five adults would likely find their patience tested.
At the end of our year with the Toyota Tacoma we found we relied on the truck much more than we originally intended. Whether it was a photo shoot in the mountains, a road trip, hauling bricks or a last-minute request to help someone move, the Tacoma was always standing by. As we fully expected from a Toyota truck, it delivered without excuse or complaint, and now that it's gone we realize all the more how useful and capable our Tacoma was.
True Market Value at service end: $26,952
Final Odometer Reading: 21,226
Best Fuel Economy: 21 mpg
Worst Fuel Economy: 11 mpg
Average Fuel Economy: 17.1 mpg
Total Body Repair Costs: $600 for repair resulting from scraping a parking structure pillar
Total Routine Maintenance Costs (over 11 months): $288.60
Additional Maintenance Costs: $100.76 (purchase broken mud flap)
Warranty Repairs: None
Non-Warranty Repairs: 1
Scheduled Dealer Visits: 4
Unscheduled Dealer Visits: 1 (to purchase broken mud flap)
Days Out of Service: 3 (for body work)
Breakdowns Stranding Driver: None
Changes to the Tacoma Since 20052006 — For 2006, a tire-pressure monitor is now standard on all Tacomas. Revised SAE testing procedures have dropped the horsepower and torque ratings slightly.
Ups and DownsUps: Strong engine, comfortable seats, excellent build quality, holds its value.
Downs: TRD suspension can be rough, soft brake pedal, automatic transmission slow to downshift.
The Bottom Line: The Tacoma is a great all-around truck. It's comfortable, tough, powerful and good-looking. Its only low points are those associated with it being a real truck — if you just need a family hauler with the occasional trip to Home Depot, stick with a car-based SUV.
Recalls and Problem HistoryRecalls: Parking brake. The cable lock nut on trucks with an automatic transmission may come loose.
Airbags. On standard-cab trucks with a bench seat, the seat position and seatbelt buckle sensor may be incorrectly aligned.
Airbags. Improper assembly of an airbag inflator in the side, curtain and knee airbags could result in increased injury during a crash.
Problem History:- Body damage as a result of scraping a parking structure pillar set us back $600.
- Leaking valve stem from one tire — fixed by Toyota of Long Beach at no charge.
- With a full load in the Tacoma's bed, one of the mud flaps broke off when we backed over a high curb. The parts cost about $100 and we installed the new one ourselves.
Dealer Service Reviews
August 2005
With just over 6000 miles on the Tacoma's odometer, we took the truck to Toyota of Santa Monica and service advisor Henry Molina helped us. The truck was dropped off in the late morning and was ready by early that afternoon. We have always had excellent service with this dealership and this time was no exception.
December 2005
If you have a good thing, stick with it. Of course we didn't listen to our own advice and decided to try another Toyota dealership — Toyota of Long Beach. The odometer had just rolled to show 15,000 miles, so we made an appointment. We sent an e-mail but no one responded. We finally phoned and brought the truck in that same week. Despite the fact that we specified only service items listed in the maintenance book, the dealership gave us the "dealer recommended" service instead. That service costs about $75 more than what Toyota recommends. After we were told of a "Coupon Special" the price came out to be $149, or about what it should have cost in the first place.
May 2006
With more than 21,000 miles on our Toyota pickup, we wisely decided to go back to Toyota of Santa Monica for the truck's final oil and filter change under our watch. Again we had excellent service.
What Consumers Say
"I received the truck with 8 miles and now I have 1100 miles. The quality is as expected — Great and Dependable. Which were the reasons for its purchase. Power is adequate but somewhat disappointing in what I thought it would be. Gas mileage is between 18-19 mpg. Rather plain inside, no thrill or gadgets which is OK. Truck is a lot larger than pre-'05."
Ed, February 22, 2006
"My first truck; researched for 6 months. This truck has been really fun. I don't need 4WD or a V6. I wanted a truck to haul things with but also to get good highway mpg so I went with the 4-cyl. The power has been fine since the engine is 2.7L, but only 20 mpg. Sticker said I'd get 27 hwy. I really wanted the Desert Sand but most dealers only had silver. Then I found a store which ordered up the Gold for me, and the build date was 2 days after I ordered! I'm 6'3", 250 and have a ton of room. My antitruck friends admit they are impressed." — Big John, June 30, 2006
"The Tacoma certainly has one of the hottest body styles of any truck in its class. The satisfaction continues with the interior comfort and style. The engine is tight with excellent performance. There is some concern over gas mileage. This con it should be noted was known at the time of purchase and today's gas prices. The bedliner and compartments are the envy of all who see the truck." — M Haddad, June 17, 2006
"I traded my '98 F-150 for an '06 Tacoma with the TRD package. I spent 6 months pricing and researching various trucks before choosing the Tacoma. I have been impressed with this truck from the first test-drive I took. The ride is great, it feels like a midsize sedan, very smooth on the freeway with little outside noise. The interior finish is impressive, everything is well laid out, I love the red gauges and the interior storage. I can see myself in this truck for the next 5-10 years!" — E. Taylor, June 16, 2006
The manufacturer provided Edmunds this vehicle for the purposes of evaluation.
Add A Comment »