INSIDE LINE

Full Test: 2007 Saturn Outlook XR FWD

Media Player

  • 2007 Saturn Outlook Picture

    2007 Saturn Outlook Picture

    Our XR model is most obviously differentiated from base XEs with body-color side mirrors and chromed door handles. | November 05, 2009

Road Test

Full Test: 2007 Saturn Outlook XR FWD

The anti-SUV, anti-minivan utility vehicle

    1 Rating
    General Motors thinks its newest crossover, this 2007 Saturn Outlook, is the next big thing: the anti-SUV, anti-minivan utility vehicle. Although we're not so sure every mom in America is going to trade in her Hummer H2 for an '07 Outlook, we do think this full-size up-to-eight-passenger vehicle is the closest any automaker has come to creating the ideal crossover. Here's why.

    Unlike some crossovers, the 2007 Saturn Outlook, which is already on sale, is not based on an existing car, truck or minivan platform. Instead General Motors used its brand-new Lambda unibody platform to underpin the Outlook and its two sister trucks, the 2008 GMC Acadia and Buick Enclave.

    Because the Outlook was designed and engineered from the outset as its own kind of people mover, it doesn't display any of the intrinsic short cuts or bandages that other crossovers usually do. Cramped built-from-a-car seating, trucky body-on-frame drivability and compromised cargo proportions are not part of the Outlook's repertoire. Instead, to really get the best of all worlds, it has a truly useful package, reasonable fuel economy and pleasing dynamics at a realistic price.

    Open range
    The 2007 Saturn Outlook is offered in two variants, XE and XR, either of which is available with front- or all-wheel drive. A wide range of prices reflects the Outlook's array, from $27,990 for a base-model XE FWD up to almost $44,000 for an absolutely loaded XR AWD with all the family-friendly amenities you could imagine.

    Every Outlook includes three rows of seating, the second and third rows of which fold flat easily for a whopping 117 cubic feet of total cargo room. Also standard is GM's highly flexible 3.6-liter DOHC V6, tuned to either 270 horsepower in single-exhaust XE form or 275 hp in the dual-exhaust XR models. Three-row side curtain airbags, traction and stability control, rollover sensing system, tire-pressure monitoring and OnStar Generation 7 (with one free year of the Safe and Sound plan), which features a crash-notification and 911 dispatch system, are also standard equipment.

    Our front-wheel-drive Outlook XR test vehicle was fitted with $4,509 in worthwhile extras, which increased its $30,290 base price to $34,799. Not inexpensive, but we think it represents an acceptable combination of essential options (leather, second-row captain's chairs, power liftgate and upgraded audio, among others) for a realistic price. If you fancy navigation, rear-seat DVD entertainment, twin glass-panel moonroofs (only the front one slides) or HID headlamps, they're available.

    Yoga flexibility
    The real story is inside the Outlook. All three rows of seating are suitable for adults, which comes in handy when the grandparents are in town. It's not perfect, though. Head- and legroom are generous, but that third row is dimensionally wide enough only for two rather than three.

    Third-row access is also class-leading. With the pull of one obvious lever, either of the captain's chairs (or 64/40-split bench halves), tilt, slide and sandwich up against the first-row seats. Combined with the low floor (relative to SUVs but not minivans), the result is easy access to the rearmost seats, even for those grandparents.

    With all seats occupied, the 20 cubic feet of cargo volume behind the third row is quite useful because the almost vertical rear glass doesn't slope into the space. We're not sure if that supplied figure includes the Outlook's modest underfloor storage (which we actually used in a pinch for space), but suffice it to say that it's larger and more easily accessible than a car's trunk.

    When not in use, the third row stows flat to offer 69 cubic feet of volume behind the second row, and we found that our tester's optional captain's chairs allowed second-row passengers to simply reach between their seats, rather than over a bench, to grab items in the cargo area.

    When all seats are folded flat, the 117-cubic-foot cargo-carrying ability of the Outlook is ginormous — even greater than the 2007 Chevrolet Tahoe's 109 cubic feet. In fact, each of the seating configurations' corresponding cargo volumes is greater than a Tahoe's despite exterior dimensions that are within inches of one another. The one measure where the Outlook falls short of the Tahoe is in overall height, where the Outlook is about 4 inches lower because it's not a body-on-frame vehicle.

    Interior faults
    As spacious as it is, we have a couple gripes with the Outlook's interior, but they're minor. Most of the important switches are Playskool simple, but some of the high-frequency-use buttons on the dash and center console are identical to the touch, too small, and sometimes not in a place where the driver's hand or eyes easily find them. Both the audio and climate controls are guilty of this foible. Also, the now-ubiquitous GM trip/vehicle configuration buttons are obscured by a spoke on the steering wheel.

    Finally, there's a shortage of medium-sized storage locations. Yes, the center armrest opens to reveal a coal mine-deep dark cavern, but utilizing the provided divider cuts off its easy access. All of the door pockets are curiously small and oddly shaped for such large doors. Perhaps as a consolation, there is a dash-top bin, but we'd be reluctant to put anything but heat-resistant goods in there. There is a personal audio player slot in the base of the center console and that's about it for a vehicle with the interior scale of a Tahoe.

    Performance testing
    Dynamically, the Outlook offers performance comparable to any competitive minivan, and that's a good thing — considering our XR's seven-passenger capacity and porky 4,723-pound test weight. The front-drive Outlook demonstrated ample giddy-up with a run to 60 mph in 8.2 seconds and a quarter-mile time of 16.6 seconds at 84.5 mph. We appreciated the engine's variable-valve timing for its ability to offer a good shove of torque in the low-rpm range and found the high-revving characteristics and double-overhead cams provided a surprisingly sporty engine note — a welcome surprise.

    We were also very pleased with the Outlook's six-speed automatic transmission. Forgive the unsolicited comparison to the Ford Edge, but the pair's similar hardware and dissimilar software compelled us. Like the Edge, the Outlook offers only two forward gear selections: D and L. However, unlike the Edge, the Outlook also allows manual up/down shifting with a thumb rocker switch on the shift lever itself. That may seem like a small detail, but an important one to us. Not only does the Outlook offer the option of bypassing the electronic transmission's frugal brain with manual shifting, it also does a much better job of knowing how and when to downshift according to the driver's desire — at about 20 percent throttle application rather than the 50-75 percent we observed in the Edge.

    Like many modern people movers, the Outlook has a standard (non-defeat) stability control system. Yet even with its safety handcuffs firmly tightened, the Outlook provides lively, precise, rack-and-pinion steering up to the 57-mph slalom-test limit. On the skid pad, the story is similar, with a modest 0.72g lateral acceleration figure. These handling numbers are surprisingly close to those of a similarly sized Mercedes-Benz GL450, but we'd also point out that the $55,000 V8-powered Benz is quite a bit quicker and much thirstier.

    The Outlook's four-wheel ventilated-disc brakes offered excellent feel, feedback and heat resistance. Despite the Outlook's high curb weight, we recorded three ABS stops from 60 mph in under 140 feet, with the best being 135 feet.

    In the real world
    In everyday driving, away from the computerized test gear, most people would say the Outlook was "a good driver," even when loaded to near capacity. Over the Thanksgiving holiday, one staffer drove his family more than 500 miles in the Outlook and reported, "The ride was as supple as a luxury SUV's, the acceleration more than ample for merging and passing and the fuel economy was far better than expected."

    Rated at 18 mpg city and 26 mpg highway, our Outlook returned a best-tank fuel economy of 19 mpg and an overall week's average of 15.5 mpg. Try that in a V8-powered three-row SUV. Trust us, it won't come close.

    Maxivan
    Unlike some of the primordial crossovers, like the Chrysler Pacifica and Ford Freestyle, the Outlook effectively delivers all the goodness of a minivan — price range, seating flexibility, fuel economy, standard safety and available options — with the SUV looks so many minivan-averse families are seeking. Unless you really need a true off-roader, or have to tow more than the Outlook's 4,500-pound rating, this Saturn is also the perfect alternative to a traditional truck-based SUV like the Ford Expedition or Chevy Tahoe.

    General Motors might be about a decade late with its V6-powered, SUV-silhouetted, unibody people hauler, but GM got it right. The full-size 2007 Saturn Outlook really is the world's first anti-SUV, anti-minivan utility vehicle, and it just might be the next big thing.

    The manufacturer provided Edmunds this vehicle for the purposes of evaluation.

    Road Test

    Second Opinions

    Karl Brauer, Editor in Chief of Edmunds.com, says:
    I've heard it said that the reason you arrive late to a party is because you want to make a grand entrance. Another benefit to waiting is that you can decide (based on attendance and activity) if the party is even worth going to. Well, the Crossover Party is officially a "can't-miss" event for any modern, mainstream automaker, and while Saturn is late, it seems to have taken full advantage of that tardiness.

    The Outlook (like the GMC Acadia and Buick Enclave) is based on the all-new Lambda unibody platform, and its combination of carlike driving dynamics and functional interior space make it a compelling entry in this exploding segment. All three rows of seating are fully functional for adults, and the process of accessing those rows is exceptionally easy. The rack-and-pinion steering, along with the four-wheel independent suspension, goes a long way toward hiding the Outlook's substantial size and weight. I feel like the transmission could be more responsive when downshifting, and the engine could be a bit more refined at high rpm, but these are minor nits. As a "cool" minivan alternative this vehicle will more than satisfy its target audience.

    Road Test Editor Brian Moody Says:
    In a word, the Saturn Outlook is "excellent." It's quiet, stylish, roomy, affordable and has the added benefit of a powerful V6 rather than a V8. Its EPA highway mileage estimate is 26 miles per gallon and we recorded 18.7 mpg on a long road trip. Not bad for an SUV that's roughly the size of a Tahoe but with much more interior space.

    Admittedly, I'm cheap. And our Outlook's $30,000 base price is at the limit for what I'm willing to spend on a family car — its as-tested price of $35,000 is starting to sound pricey to me but the level of refinement, comfort and versatility makes spending that much seem like a bargain. And something tells me that's exactly the kind of thing Saturn customers expect.

    The Outlook is quite frankly the perfect alternative to a minivan. It has three rows of seats, an available video system and plenty of cargo space even with the third row of seats in place. Vue owners can graduate without leaving the comfort of no-haggle dealerships or compromising their nose for value.

    Road Test

    Stereo Evaluation

    Overall Grade: B-

    Brand Name: N/A (supplied by Delphi)
    Watts: 300
    Speakers: 9
    Optional Equipment: Advanced Audio package includes extra speakers, subwoofer and aux input jack
    Price if optional: $805
    CD Player: Six-disc in-dash changer
    Formats: MP3, CD, WMA and AAC without text support.
    Aux Jack: Yes
    iPod-Specific Connection: No
    Hard Drive: No
    Bluetooth for phone: No, OnStar hands-free calling is offered.
    Subwoofer: Yes

    How does it sound: C+
    Sound quality is average or perhaps a little above average but separation is lacking. Bass is there but tends toward boomy and is not sharp or punchy. It's a similar story with the highs. They're there but don't really add any detail or crispness to the sound. The system sounds OK the way it is, but no one will mistake it for a true premium sound system, which is too bad because we're sure the Outlook's spacious interior would make an excellent space for a premium Bose or Alpine stereo.

    While the audio system is certainly not terrible, we expect a little more given that it's an upgraded stereo and it adds an extra $800 to the price tag.

    How does it work: B
    Most controls are well placed and easy to use/understand. GM's new radios look good and are not cluttered with confusing buttons and switches, the knobs feel nice and the display on non-navigation-equipped models is clear and easy to read. Steering-wheel-mounted controls are large and intuitive. If this is the future of GM audio systems in terms of materials and function, then we're impressed.

    Special features: The upgraded audio system gets you an auxiliary jack for connecting handheld MP3 players. This is a must-have in the segment and we'd expect the "different" Saturn Outlook to have it — it does, so we're happy. A navigation system and rear-seat DVD entertainment system are optional but Bluetooth is MIA. Although OnStar has a calling feature that sort of achieves Bluetooth's goal, it is not as reliable and many customers will need to have an extra phone number for their car in addition to home, work and cell numbers.

    Conclusion: We're not sure most Saturn customers will be looking for stellar sound systems but the Outlook is going to attract a lot of attention from outside the Springhill crowd. Add the Tahoe's Bose speakers to this audio system and there will be little to complain about. — Brian Moody

    Sort By:

    Sort By:

    Close

    Share on Facebook Share on Facebook
    Share on Twitter Share on Twitter

    Advertisement

    Speed Read

    Featured Specs

    • Standard three-row seating
    • 3.6-liter 275-hp V6
    • $30,290 base price

    What Works

    Supple ride and steering; interior size and configurability; attractive styling inside and out.

    What Needs Work

    A couple interior design details lack the thoughtfulness displayed in the rest of the vehicle.

    Tags

    Specs & Performance

    Vehicle
    Model year2007
    MakeSaturn
    ModelOutlook
    StyleXR 4dr SUV (3.6L 6cyl 6A)
    Base MSRP$30,290
    As-tested MSRP$34,799
    Drivetrain
    Drive typeFront-wheel drive
    Engine typeV6
    Displacement (cc/cu-in)3564cc (217 cu-in)
    Valvetrain32-valves, DOHC, variable intake and exhaust timing
    Compression ratio (x:1)10.2
    Horsepower (hp @ rpm)275 @ 6600
    Torque (lb-ft @ rpm)251 @ 3200
    Transmission typeSix-speed automatic
    Chassis
    Suspension, frontIndependent, MacPherson Struts, coil springs and stabilizer bar
    Suspension, rearIndependent, multilink, coil springs, lower control arms and stabilizer bar
    Steering typeSpeed-proportional power steering
    Turning circle (ft.)40.4
    Tire brandGoodyear
    Tire modelFortera HL Edition all-season
    Tire typeall season
    Tire size, frontP255/65R18 109S
    Tire size, rearP255/65R18 109S
    Wheel size18 X 7.5
    Wheel materialalloy
    Brakes, frontFront ventilated disc - Rear ventilated disc
    Brakes, rearventilated disc
    Track Test Results
    0-45 mph (sec.)5.3
    0-60 mph (sec.)8.2
    0-75 mph (sec.)12.8
    1/4-mile (sec. @ mph)16.6 @ 84.5
    Braking, 30-0 mph (ft.)34
    60-0 mph (ft.)135
    Slalom, 6 x 100 ft. (mph)57.1
    Skid pad, 200-ft. diameter (lateral g)0.72
    Sound level @ idle (dB)45.2
    @ Full throttle (dB)78.1
    @ 70 mph cruise (dB)66.0
    Test Driver Ratings & Comments
    Acceleration commentsThe best acceleration run was achieved with Trac off and a hint of wheelspin off the line. Upshifts are well damped and do not cause any unwelcome "head-toss." While there is no redline indicated, wide-open throttle shifts occur at 6,800 rpm. By the way, this engine sounds terrific, unlike some other V6 CUVs we've recently tested. Either the "D" or "L6" shifter position works equally well, with the L6 position always offering the option of manual shifts — while the "D" position will not allow operation of the button shifter. There is a bit of a dip in acceleration in the middle of 3rd gear. (Note: The brake pedal got very soft by the end of the third quarter-mile run.)
    Braking ratingGood
    Braking commentsIn normal, everyday driving, the brake pedal feels firm and offers the kind of feedback we like; however, at the limit of a full-ABS stop, the long pedal travel and mushy resistance are not optimal. While there is good stopping power (three successive stops under 140 feet) and the ABS remains quiet and effective, we did find fading effectiveness during the higher-speed acceleration tests where the brake pedal became noticeably soft and the stopping power waned.
    Handling ratingAverage
    Handling commentsAs with most family-oriented vehicles, the stability system cannot be fully defeated. As a result, the slalom and skid pad performances are limited by the Outlook's electronic "nanny" rather than its suspension and tires. That said, the steering is accurate and responsive, if a little too light and effortless for my taste. I could feel that given the opportunity (disabling stability control) that the Outlook would eventually oversteer in the slalom test. On the skid pad, that same nanny keeps the understeer at bay and applies the brakes before the steering becomes ineffective.
    Testing Conditions
    Elevation (ft.)1121
    Temperature (°F)57.4
    Wind (mph, direction)2.5
    Fuel Consumption
    EPA fuel economy (mpg)18 City 26 Highway
    Edmunds observed (mpg)15.7
    Fuel tank capacity (U.S. gal.)22
    Dimensions & Capacities
    Curb weight, mfr. claim (lbs.)4,722 mfr (4723 as tested)
    Length (in.)200.7
    Width (in.)78.2
    Height (in.)69.9
    Wheelbase (in.)118.9
    Track, front (in.)67.1
    Track, rear (in.)67.1
    Legroom, front (in.)41.3
    Legroom, rear (in.)36.9
    Legroom, 3rd row (in.)33.2
    Headroom, front (in.)40.4
    Headroom, rear (in.)39.3
    Headroom, 3rd row (in.)38.4
    Shoulder room, front (in.)61.9
    Shoulder room, rear (in.)61.1
    Shoulder room, 3rd row (in.)57.8
    Seating capacity7
    Cargo volume (cu-ft)19.7
    Max. cargo volume, seats folded (cu-ft)117.0
    Warranty
    Bumper-to-bumper3 years/36,000 miles
    Powertrain5 years/100,000 miles
    Corrosion6 years/100,000 miles
    Roadside assistance5 years/100,000 miles
    Free scheduled maintenanceNot available
    Safety
    Front airbagsStandard
    Side airbagsStandard dual front
    Head airbagsStandard front, rear and third row
    Antilock brakes4-wheel ABS
    Electronic brake enhancementsElectronic brakeforce distribution
    Traction controlStandard
    Stability controlStandard
    Rollover protectionStandard
    Tire-pressure monitoring systemtire pressure monitoring
    Emergency assistance systemNot available
    NHTSA crash test, driverNot Tested
    NHTSA crash test, passengerNot Tested
    NHTSA crash test, side frontNot Tested
    NHTSA crash test, side rearNot Tested
    NHTSA rollover resistanceNot Tested
    CollapseSpecs and Performance Expand Collapse

    Advertisement