INSIDE LINE

Follow-Up Test: 2005 Pontiac Grand Prix GXP

Road Test

Follow-Up Test: 2005 Pontiac Grand Prix GXP

Grand Prix Extreme

    1 Rating
    Recipe for muscle car glory: Take one run-of-the-mill car, add a powerful V8 engine and give it a cool-sounding three-letter moniker, like GTO. That formula created the world's first muscle car four decades ago, and now it has been applied to the 2005 Pontiac Grand Prix GXP.

    Pontiac's engineers have stuffed an all-aluminum V8 engine into the Grand Prix, fortified its suspension, added bigger brakes, 18-inch wheels and restyled front and rear fascias.

    It's not only the first eight-cylinder Grand Prix in years, it's also the most expensive GP ever. Base price is a heady $29,335, and our heavily optioned test car stickered for $32,600, which is about the same as an Infiniti G35 and a Dodge Charger RT.

    Muscle Car Hardware
    The GXP's 5.3-liter pushrod small-block V8 is very similar to the engine used in Chevy's Silverado pickup, but Pontiac replaced the iron block with a lighter aluminum unit for this and other front-wheel-drive applications. Other changes include high-flow cylinder heads, a higher compression ratio and cylinder deactivation technology for improved fuel economy.

    Output is 303 horsepower at 5,600 rpm, and 323 pound-feet of torque at 4,400 rpm, all of which is funneled into a four-speed automatic transmission controlled with Pontiac's TAPshift paddle shifters.

    Underneath, the GXP's stiffer springs reduce ride height by 9mm, and Bilstein struts tighten up the suspension. A larger 17.2mm rear sway bar was added to reduce body roll, and forged aluminum five-spoke wheels with Bridgestone Potenza tires are also part of the package.

    Oddly enough, the GXP's wheels measure 18-by-8 inches in front and 18-by-7 inches in back and the 255/45R18 front tires are fatter than the 225/50R18 rears. Usually it's the other way around, and the combo simply looks strange. When we asked Pontiac why all four corners didn't get the 8-inch wheel, we were told a computer simulation determined this is the optimal setup for handling and acceleration.

    We think Pontiac's engineers should leave their computer terminals for the test track every once in a while. Although the GXP's upgraded suspension and oddball wheel and tire combination rides well enough, it doesn't supply the off-the-line traction or cornering grip we expected.

    Torque Steer City
    Stuffing a V8 into a front-wheel-drive platform is a surefire recipe for torque steer, and Pontiac's engineers have cooked up plenty of it. Hammering the pedal at any speed causes the car to dart around like there's a drunk behind the wheel. And laying into it from a dead stop, even with GXP's traction control turned on, results in immediate wheelspin, which slows the Grand Prix's acceleration.

    Pontiac claims the GXP will run zero to 60 mph in 5.9 seconds, but our best run was a tire-smoking 6.7 seconds. We've yet to wring out a Hemi-powered Charger RT, which is the GXP's closest competitor, but our long-term Magnum RT, which weighs 500 pounds more than the Pontiac and 150 pounds more than a Hemi Charger, hits 60 mph in 6.8 seconds.

    Once the GXP hooks up, however, it does leave the larger Magnum in the dust, running the quarter-mile in 14.6 seconds at 95.4 mph. And it sounds great doing it, with just the right amount of rumble.

    The torque steer also limits the GXP's appeal on a mountain road, especially when exiting slow corners. Numb and disconnected steering, a nose-heavy feel and a nasty delay before the transmission actually reacts to the driver's "taps" also sap the GXP of fun-to-drive points. Even the design of the TAPshift "paddles" mounted on either side of the steering wheel should be better. As it is, they're counterintuitive. Pushing forward shifts up, while pulling back downshifts.

    Its braking performance is good but not great. The Pontiac's cross-drilled rotors (12.7 inches front, 12 inches rear) are nice to look at, but the calipers are only two-piston in front and single-piston out back. The results are good resistance to overheating, a 60-0-mph performance of 124.1 feet and fair pedal feel.

    High Content, Low Style
    The overall look of the GXP isn't much different than the standard Grand Prix save for the big shiny wheels and drilled brakes. Other extras include an aggressive front fascia with lower air inlets, restyled rear fascia with dual exhaust cutouts, a rear deck spoiler and air ducts in the front fenders.

    Inside, the Grand Prix's interior is on the tight side for such a large car, but the GXP gets brushed aluminum interior accents and an engine-turned metal gauge cluster that hearkens back to the early days of Pontiac performance. Fit and finish, however, is lackluster, with large expanses of hard plastic and ill-fitting panels that look more rental car than muscle car.

    Pontiac did manage to get the front seats to feel just right and the feature content is impressive. Stability control, OnStar, steering wheel radio controls, a 60/40 split-folding rear seat, a head-up display, keyless entry and a CD player are standard. Our test car added leather seating with suede inserts, a power sunroof, XM Satellite Radio, a special paint color called Blue-Green Crystal, automatic dual-zone climate control and a remote vehicle starter.

    Final Thoughts
    Ten years ago we might have looked at a 300-hp V8 Pontiac sedan more favorably, but today there are over a dozen cars competing in the $30,000-$35,000 sport sedan segment, and the GXP just can't compete with its rear-wheel-drive rivals like the Charger.

    The V8 power is nice, but with its crude interior, vague steering and massive torque steer the 2005 Pontiac Grand Prix GXP is never much fun.

    Sort By:

    Sort By:

    Close

    Share on Facebook Share on Facebook
    Share on Twitter Share on Twitter

    Advertisement

    Speed Read

    Featured Specs

    • 303-horsepower V8
    • "TAPshift" 4-speed shiftable automatic
    • 18-inch alloy wheels

    What Works

    V8 rumble, comfortable seats, agreeable highway ride.

    What Needs Work

    Clumsy handling, lackluster fit and finish, overpowering torque steer, numb steering feel.

    Tags

    Specs & Performance

    Vehicle
    Model year2005
    MakePontiac
    ModelGrand Prix
    StyleGXP
    Base MSRP$29,335
    As-tested MSRP$32,600
    Drivetrain
    Drive typeFWD
    Engine typeV8
    Displacement (cc/cu-in)5.3
    Horsepower (hp @ rpm)303@5600
    Torque (lb-ft @ rpm)323@4400
    Transmission type4-speed automatic w/ sportshift
    Chassis
    Suspension, frontIndependent w/ Stabilizer
    Suspension, rearIndependent w/ Stabilizer
    Steering typePower rack and pinion
    Tire brandBridgestone
    Tire modelPotenza
    Tire size, front255/55R18
    Tire size, rear225/50R18
    Brakes, front4-wheel disc w/ ABS
    Track Test Results
    0-45 mph (sec.)4.4
    0-60 mph (sec.)6.7
    0-75 mph (sec.)9.7
    1/4-mile (sec. @ mph)14.57@95.35
    Braking, 30-0 mph (ft.)29.39
    60-0 mph (ft.)124.17
    Slalom, 6 x 100 ft. (mph)56.0
    Skid pad, 200-ft. diameter (lateral g)37.4
    Sound level @ idle (dB)45
    @ Full throttle (dB)74
    @ 70 mph cruise (dB)68
    Test Driver Ratings & Comments
    Acceleration commentsTraction is a major problem. The engine is moderately powerful, but the real root of the problem is that in a front wheel drive platform weight transfer pulls weight off the drive wheels under hard acceleration. With traction control on the wheels still spin off the line, then the program kicks in and cuts the power way back. With it turned off wheel spin is even worse. Torque steer is a major problem in this vehicle, under full throttle accleration the car actually tries to swerve. The transmission shifts at 5,000 rpm, despite the 6,000 rpm redline. The "Tapshift" paddle shifters on the steering wheel are very poorly designed, as you have to push the paddle to upshift and pull to downshift, which is exactly opposite every other paddle shifter design on the market.
    Braking ratingAverage
    Braking commentsNose dive is significant under hard braking. ABS noise and vibration are both obtrusive. The pedal feels mushy and is difficult to regulate. We're not entirely sure why the rear discs are cross-drilled, that is extremely uncommon. Stopping distances are only average for a sedan this size with so-called high performance brakes.
    Handling ratingPoor
    Handling commentsThe GXP is extremely difficult to drive in the slalom. Combine numb GM steering with a nose-heavy front-wheel-drive vehicle prone to torque-steer and it becomes a real handful. The car wants to rotate on a hair trigger, and once it comes around it is very difficult to correct. Stability control did not seem to be functioning, or if it was we didn't notice.
    Testing Conditions
    Elevation (ft.)1050
    Temperature (°F)103
    Wind (mph, direction)3 mph NE
    Fuel Consumption
    EPA fuel economy (mpg)18 City 27 Highway
    Edmunds observed (mpg)11.48
    Fuel tank capacity (U.S. gal.)17
    Dimensions & Capacities
    Curb weight, mfr. claim (lbs.)3600
    Length (in.)198.3
    Width (in.)71.6
    Height (in.)55.9
    Wheelbase (in.)110.5
    Legroom, front (in.)42.2
    Legroom, rear (in.)36.2
    Headroom, front (in.)38.8
    Headroom, rear (in.)36.2
    Seating capacity5
    Cargo volume (cu-ft)16 cu. Ft
    Max. cargo volume, seats folded (cu-ft)57 cu. Ft.
    Warranty
    Bumper-to-bumper3 years / 36,000 miles
    Powertrain3 years / 36,000 miles
    Corrosion6 years / 100,000 miles
    Roadside assistance3 years / 36,000 miles
    Free scheduled maintenanceN/A
    Safety
    Front airbagsStandard
    Side airbagsNot Available
    Head airbagsOptional
    Antilock brakesStandard
    Electronic brake enhancementsStandard
    Traction controlStandard
    Stability controlStandard
    Rollover protectionNot Available
    Emergency assistance systemOptional
    NHTSA crash test, driverGood
    NHTSA crash test, passengerAverage
    NHTSA crash test, side frontAverage
    NHTSA crash test, side rearAverage
    NHTSA rollover resistanceGood
    CollapseSpecs and Performance Expand Collapse

    Advertisement