INSIDE LINE

Long-Term Test: 2005 Kia Spectra5

Road Test

Long-Term Test: 2005 Kia Spectra5

Introduction

    0 Ratings
    Not everyone can afford a Bentley, or even a Buick for that matter. Money aside, many of us just want a practical, budget-friendly solution to our transportation needs. But does that mean we should look dorky every time we hop into that low-buck bucket?

    Attempting to offer little style along with value is the new 2005 Kia Spectra5, another entry in the emerging class of compact hatchbacks and wagons. This is actually the second generation of the Spectra five-door, and this time around Kia promises the car is up to Toyota standards.

    We know brands like Hyundai and Kia are helping to keep the all-important sub-$20,000 segment alive, but are the Korean imports really on equal footing with competitors like the Ford Focus, Mazda 3 and Toyota Matrix? We couldn't think of a better way to answer that question than to add a Spectra5 to our long-term fleet. Maybe it will be just another compact car. Or maybe it will change the way we think about budget Kias.

    In fact, we can't wait to see which staffers' misconceptions lead them to weasel out of driving the Spectra5 for the weekend, thinking themselves "too good" for an economy car. They'll have to get over that, because we're keeping this Kia for a year and pressing it into duty as a family car, commuter car, road-trip wagon and all-around daily companion.

    Like other small wagons, the Spectra5 is billed as a sporty version of its sedan sibling. The extra dose of attitude comes courtesy of its standard body cladding, 16-inch alloy wheels, black mesh grille, foglights and rear roof spoiler.

    Under the hood is a DOHC 2.0-liter inline four-cylinder with variable valve timing — Kia's first variable-valve-timing engine. It makes 138 horsepower and 136 pound-feet of torque. To keep things relaxed in the city, we selected a four-speed automatic transmission to go with it (a five-speed manual is available for those who prefer to shift their own gears).

    For an economy car, the Kia Spectra5 comes with a long list of standard equipment, including four-wheel disc brakes, seat-mounted side airbags in front, full-length side curtain airbags, air conditioning, a six-speaker CD stereo, a leather-wrapped steering wheel and full power accessories. We added a sunroof, antilock brakes, cruise control and floor mats as options. We're a little disappointed that ABS isn't standard, but at just $400 for this stand-alone option, we can't complain too loudly. The total sticker on our test car is $17,400.

    Early impressions are mostly positive. Several editors commented that acceleration was surprisingly peppy. Production Editor Caroline Pardilla put it this way: "I thought it was going to feel like a rental Chevy Aveo or my '98 Corolla, but when I pressed the accelerator I got more power than I expected." Content Editor Warren Clarke also expressed surprise and described the car as "light and nimble," making it "kinda fun to drive."

    Even though we like the Spectra's off-the-line spunk, more than one editor noted there isn't much extra power at higher speeds. When we track-test the car, we suspect it will deliver a quick 0-to-30-mph time but a slightly disappointing 0-to-60.

    Inside, the car is surprising in many respects. The rear seat has adequate room for adults, the front seats are comfortable and the pleasing tactile nature of the buttons and switches belies the car's $16,000 base price.

    One downside is the large number of hard plastic surfaces, which give the interior a cheap look at first glance. Also, the wagon configuration allows for a little more storage space, but with the rear seats in use, we would hesitate to call it spacious.

    We'll have to keep reminding ourselves about the price.

    In the meantime, we'll continue to use the Spectra5 the way you would in our quest to find out whether this Kia's got what it takes to go up against the class leaders. Check back for our next report.

    Current Odometer: 1,270
    Best Fuel Economy: 19.6 mpg
    Worst Fuel Economy: 18.9 mpg
    Average Fuel Economy (over the life of the vehicle): 19.3 mpg
    Body Repair Costs: None
    Maintenance Costs: None
    Problems: None.

    Road Test

    June 2005

    At the end of the first quarter of its long-term test, our 2005 Kia Spectra5 has more going for it than just its eye-popping Spark Blue paint. A lot more. With over 7,000 miles on the odometer, the Spectra5 has zoomed in and out of our test garage for the past few months without a mechanical issue to report. Unfortunately, body repairs are another matter.

    It's not that the Spectra5 was involved in multiple accidents. Instead, we experienced a reoccurring issue with the same exterior part, the Spectra5's super-low front spoiler.

    High-performance sports cars regularly visit our garage, many of which are outfitted with low-profile spoilers. Expert drivers that we are, we know how to work around them. That basically means take the ramps at the appropriate angle and don't rip the spoiler off. Unfortunately, this is a lesson that hasn't translated well to the Spectra5. Its spoiler has suffered not one, but three casualties at our merciless hands.

    The first incident was the worst and required the spoiler to be removed the rest of the way in order to move it to a body shop for repair. We mistakenly bypassed the Kia dealer and took it to an independent body shop first. They reattached the spoiler, but unfortunately used glue and not the bolts recommended by Kia. Subsequently, the spoiler sagged on a hot road trip to Phoenix and needed to be fixed again.

    The third time it took another hard knock, so we decided to retrace our steps and called Kia to see if there was a recommended fix. There was. Kia bolted the spoiler back into position, saying we may scrape the spoiler again, but there was no chance it would come off. After one week back on the road, we have no additional incidents to report. It appears we're getting the hang of negotiating the Spectra5's low spoiler and hopefully will proceed through the coming months without incident.

    Aside from our Los Angeles-to-Phoenix run, the Kia has taken excursions to the desert oasis of Palm Springs and the home of bipartisanship, Sacramento. In between road trips, it has accumulated hundreds of slogging commute miles. Overall, drivers have found little to complain about. The Spectra5 has received universal praise for its well-shaped and supportive front seats, even from the road-trippers.

    When it comes to power, most were pleased with the Kia's low-end torque, but found the engine came up a little short during freeway acceleration. The little wagon's tight handling helps offset its occasional lack of power. On the Phoenix trip, editor Erin Riches noted, "I had trouble keeping up with aggressive SUV drivers on the straightaways of U.S. 93, but I could reel them back in on the curvy stretches."

    Priced under $20,000, most people wouldn't expect the Kia to offer much in the way of amenities, and this Spectra5 is a pretty stripped-down racy version that's designed to appeal to a young buyer. The stereo system received good marks for its sound and simple controls, but the camp became divided over whether good sound was good enough when you're chasing the youth market. Some complained about speaker distortion, which they feel is bad enough to overshadow the stereo's positive notes.

    With one quarter of our test behind us, we're looking forward to several more months in the Kia Spectra5.

    Current Odometer: 7,195
    Best Fuel Economy: 29.4 mpg
    Worst Fuel Economy: 21.8 mpg
    Average Fuel Economy (over the life of the vehicle): 23.3 mpg
    Body Repair Costs: $175
    Maintenance Costs: None
    Problems: None

    Road Test

    September 2005

    Good things come in blue packages with Kia labels. At least that's what we're discovering as we continue to put our long-term Kia Spectra5 through the paces of daily driving adventures. One wouldn't expect the cute little wagon to have a sporting side, but its handling and braking abilities are impressive.

    New Vehicle Reviews Editor Jeff Bryan had some interesting comments regarding the Kia's cornering ability. "My daily commute includes a trip down Sunset Boulevard through Beverly Hills, a busy road famous for its abrupt curves and hidden traffic signals. Each day I found myself edging the Spectra5 faster and faster on the turns without a significant increase in drama. Sure, there is a bit of body roll, but the suspension hangs on pretty tight and is quite forgiving as it nears its limits. The four-wheel disc ABS brakes are also quite strong and have a good feel."

    Our speeding editor found the Spectra5's 2.0-liter engine adequate in this environment, but not quite as capable as the underpinnings. "Acceleration can be sluggish at times," he wrote in his notes, "and the situation is made worse by the Kia's lazy automatic transmission, which makes the car lunge at nearly every shift." Kia has already addressed this issue by introducing an improved automatic tranny for 2006 models. Though engine power is not the Spectra5's strong suit, Jeff found the car less frustrating to accelerate than an automatic-equipped Scion xA we recently tested.

    Other upbeat points were peppered throughout the Spectra's logbook, such as sliding sun visors, a seat height adjuster and leather accents on the steering wheel, shift knob and parking brake handle.

    Our Spectra5 hasn't been frustration-free, however. A symphony of buzzes and rattles plague our tester's sunroof and headliner, and several editors have taken issue with the stereo. Though easy to use, the system easily overpowers the speakers. In fact, one of the rear speakers is either loose or blown, as any amount of bass makes the cabin fill with unpleasant reverberations. We'll be sure to have the dealer check out these issues at our next service visit.

    The hot summer months have taken their toll on fuel economy, which has dipped to a record low of 17.5 mpg. Heavy use of the air conditioning is undoubtedly the main culprit. Indeed, as temperatures return to the more typical Southern California 70s, we're already noticing an upswing in the Spectra5's last few tanks.

    And no long-term review of our Kia would be complete without mention of the car's infamous front spoiler. This styling add-on continues to provoke grimaces from drivers who scrape the spoiler turning into driveways and crossing rain gutters in the roadway. The spoiler is not especially large, but the front overhang (distance from the front wheels to the front bumper) is rather long. We've lost count of the number of times the spoiler has been repaired, but for now it's staying firmly attached. At this point, we're waiting for the plastic part to grind itself to smithereens before we have this styling gimmick repaired again.

    We look forward to more time behind the wheel of our Spectra5. The little Kia's driving dynamics should continue to impress, but only time will tell if we can get the buzzes and rattles exorcised.

    Current Odometer: 10,895
    Best Fuel Economy: 28.9 mpg
    Worst Fuel Economy: 17.5 mpg
    Average Fuel Economy (over the life of the vehicle): 23.6 mpg
    Body Repair Costs: None
    Maintenance Costs: None
    Problems: Buzz/rattles from sunroof and rear speaker.

    Road Test

    December 2005

    Knowledge and experience can be drawbacks. When it comes to evaluating cars, a fresh and almost ignorant approach can sometimes be best. Well, let's make that a sort of informed ignorance — it helps to know the difference between a connecting rod and a tie rod. The truth is new-car shoppers don't have years of experience sitting on their shoulders when visiting the local Kia dealer. And that's a good thing because the Kia Spectra5 is a fine car when judged on its own merits. It offers a sporty attitude, value, a little bit of style and an excellent warranty.

    However, if you have the ghost of Kias past breathing down your neck you may carry a lot of baggage into the parking garage as you prepare to pilot the Spectra5 home for the long weekend. Inevitably, some editors don't look forward to driving our long-term Kia Spectra5 but everyone agrees that after a few minutes behind the wheel they wondered why they didn't look forward to it.

    Road Test Editor Brian Moody made this observation; "I've driven the Spectra many times and have always liked it — I can't understand why I have an 'oh no' feeling when its keys land on my desk. Am I just stupid?" Aside from leaving the door wide open to ridicule, the short answer is "No." Executive Editor Richard Homan gave a simple explanation, "You're not stupid; it's just that you remember previous Kias." So Mr. Moody's experience is working against him in this case.

    In fact, it's those staff members who experience the Kia Spectra5 in a vacuum who have the most positive comments. Production Editor Caroline Pardilla said simply, "It's peppy. When I jump away from a stoplight quickly, other drivers look puzzled." Associate Editor Warren Clarke says, "The interior is surprisingly roomy. This is probably the perfect city car."

    And many staffers went on to praise the Spectra5's sporty performance. Senior Content Editor Erin Riches even went as far as to call the Spectra a "sleeper" and recounted a story of how she outmaneuvered a guy in a lowered Honda Accord thanks to the Spectra's "quick-shifting transmission and fairly tight suspension." And although she praised the 2.0-liter, inline four's power saying "good midrange torque and great power off the line," she also indicated that the engine was a "little too noisy at high rpm."

    While we find the Kia Spectra5 does its best work around town and commuting to and from the office, Manager of Vehicle Testing Kelly Toepke took it on a road trip and commented on the seats. "The seats are incredibly comfortable and provide very good lateral and lumbar support. After a long 6-plus-hour drive, my back was no less for wear. I can't say that about many luxury cars."

    It's these types of comments, combined with the fact that the little blue wagon has had no mechanical problems in more than 15,000 miles of driving, that has a lot of us rethinking what the logo on the grille really means.

    While we ponder that deep topic, we'll continue to use the Spectra5 exactly the way we have been; for short trips to the supermarket, commuting, hauling boxes of clothes to the Salvation Army and the occasional road trip. Whatever we throw at this little car, we're incapable of breaking its spirit, and we suspect that won't change in the coming months.

    Current Odometer: 15,023
    Best Fuel Economy: 26.4 mpg
    Worst Fuel Economy: 19.7 mpg
    Average Fuel Economy (over the life of the vehicle): 23.4 mpg
    Body Repair Costs: None
    Maintenance Costs: None
    Problems: None

    Road Test

    Wrap-Up

    Why We Bought It
    How It Drove
    Inside the Cabin
    Summing Up
    Changes to the Spectra5 since 2005
    Ups and Downs
    Recalls and Problem History
    Dealer Service Reviews
    What Consumers Say

    Why We Bought It
    Some cars are objects of lust and envy. These are the rides that garner admiring looks as you cruise down the boulevard, the ones valets park next to the front door of fancy restaurants.

    The Kia Spectra5 is not one of those cars, not by a long shot, for reasons that go beyond its clearance-rack price tag. For many, memories of yesterday's less-than-stellar Kias have left a sour taste, causing them to view the automaker's efforts with scorn and suspicion.

    But are these negative feelings warranted, or just unfortunate holdovers from another era? Is this new-for-2005 Kia wagon truly lacking, or is it an economy compact capable of giving class leaders like the Mazda 3, Ford Focus and Toyota Matrix a run for their money? Deciding that no one should have to suffer for the sins of his father, we added the Spectra5 to our fleet, to see how it holds up for a year of schlepping, cruising and hauling.

    As budget wagons go, the Spectra5 is reasonably easy on the eyes, with rocker panel moldings, 16-inch alloy wheels, black mesh grille and a rear roof spoiler giving it a somewhat sporty look. Its standard features list didn't leave us wanting, either. With air conditioning, seat-mounted front side airbags, full-length side curtain airbags, dual heated outside mirrors, a six-speaker CD player, a leather-wrapped steering wheel and full power accessories included in the price of admission, the Spectra5 offers a lot for your economy-car dollar.

    Packing 138 horsepower and 136 pound-feet of torque, our Spectra5's 2.0-liter inline four is the first engine from Kia to utilize variable valve timing. We chose to team it with a four-speed automatic transmission, but a five-speed manual is available for those who'd rather handle the shifting themselves.

    We sweetened the pot with a few options: antilock brakes, cruise control, a sunroof and floor mats. These extra additions made nary a dent in its price tag, which came in at a very affordable $17,940.

    How It Drove
    Performance-wise, a highlight of the Spectra5 was its abundance of low-end torque. The wagon boasted the sort of moxie that left smiles on our editors' faces. "It always surprises me how much get-up-and-go this car has," says Production Editor Caroline Pardilla. "I think it also surprises the drivers of the sports cars next to me when the light turns green. I love that!"

    The wagon offered abundant power for driving around town, but some editors noted that it was less impressive at high speeds. "The engine is not as strong on the freeway, but acceleration is still quite passable for an economy hatchback," says Senior Content Editor Erin Riches. Additionally, there were gripes regarding the engine's acoustics, which our editors described as "coarse" and "loud in midrange."

    But otherwise, our Spectra5's handling didn't disappoint. "I drove the Spectra5 back-to-back with a Suzuki Aerio and immediately noticed how much tighter the handling was on the Kia," says Senior Editor Ed Hellwig. "The steering is still a little wobbly, but the overall ride is much better." Content Editor Warren Clarke had this to say: "The Spectra5 was lighter and nimbler than I'd anticipated. It offers more fun behind the wheel than most would expect."

    Erin took the Spectra5 on a road trip from Southern California to Arizona and came back impressed with the car's ability to retain its composure when cornering. "I had trouble keeping up with aggressive SUV drivers on the straightaways of U.S. 93, but I could reel them back in on the curvy stretches," she says.

    Another editor agrees, saying, "My daily commute includes a trip down Sunset Boulevard through Beverly Hills, a busy road famous for its abrupt curves. Every day I found myself edging the Spectra5 faster and faster on the turns without a significant increase in drama. Sure, there is a bit of body roll, but the suspension hangs on pretty tight and is quite forgiving as it nears its limits." And we were able to bring the Kia to a halt without undue hassle; editors praised the Spectra5's solid brake pedal feel.

    But there was little praise for our Spectra5's front spoiler. The styling add-on was subject to a multitude of scrapes from drivers turning into driveways and crossing rain gutters in the roadway. The spoiler isn't especially huge, but its long overhang translates into low clearance. Although the damage suffered was minor, it resulted in a couple of trips to the body shop, with a cumulative repair bill of $175.

    Our Spectra5's mileage was a bit disappointing. EPA estimates are 24 miles per gallon in the city and 34 mpg on the highway. Our Kia averaged 23.1 mpg. True, we did spend quite a few hours gridlocked in city traffic, but we think our wagon's low figures offer more proof that the EPA needs to tweak its rating system.

    Inside the Cabin
    Our Kia's cabin was a reasonably welcoming place to be. "Its seats are supportive with large head restraints and soft cushioning on the door panel for the driver's left arm," says Erin. We also cheered the "smooth, easy-to-grasp leather" that wraps the steering wheel. On the other hand, there were plenty of hard plastic surfaces, a fact that made the Spectra5 look cheap at first blush.

    The cabin offered good nighttime illumination. "Every button and knob lights up so that everything is just as accessible as it is during the day," says Erin. "It's a very pleasant car to drive at night."

    True to its compact nature, the Spectra5's cabin wasn't exactly brimming with spaciousness. Its rear seats were roomy enough for adults, though; "this wagon definitely has one of the best backseats in its class," says one editor. And elsewhere, the interior offered a few pleasant surprises. "The center console is small, but there's a nice assortment of lined, open slots — one big enough for a cell phone and another big enough to allow you to lay CDs flat. There are also large cupholders and large door bins."

    Our editors had gripes regarding noise level within the cabin. Annoying buzzes and rattles were often heard coming from the headliner and sunroof. The issue wasn't remedied, since the dealer was unable to duplicate the problem.

    The Spectra5's stereo drew mixed reviews. It was praised for its sound quality and intuitive controls, but some felt the sound, though good, wasn't good enough to woo the youth market, a market that's of prime importance for a vehicle in this price range.

    Summing Up
    The Spectra5's abundance of low-end torque delighted our editors. When driven around town, the car was peppy and responsive. However, the engine wasn't as impressive on the freeway, offering power that, while decent for its class, was more adequate than abundant. The Kia's inline four also took some hits for being loud and coarse-sounding at high speeds.

    Otherwise, handling was impressive for its class. The Spectra5 was surprisingly nimble, and shone when experienced on tight curves. The fun was somewhat marred by the car's front spoiler, whose low clearance resulted in trips to the repair shop.

    Despite an abundance of hard plastic surfaces, the Spectra5's cabin was an enjoyable place to be. Rear seats were roomy for its class, and the cabin offered a decent array of storage spaces. However, the cabin's occasional buzzes and rattles were irksome. The car's sound system was user-friendly and satisfactory, but may not have enough juice and clarity to impress discerning younger buyers.

    Overall, we found the Kia Spectra5 to be likable and competent. We were impressed by the fact that, save for the nagging rattles, the Spectra5 proved problem-free during its year spent in our care.

    Competitors like the Mazda 3 and Ford Focus ZX5 offer a more refined engine and better handling, so if ride quality matters most to you, the Kia isn't your best bet. But the Spectra5 offers outstanding interior room and storage space, at a price that's among the lowest in its class. If you're looking for an economy compact that shines in these areas, run, don't walk, to a Kia dealer near you.

    True Market Value at service end: $12,509
    Depreciation: $4,891 or 28% of original paid price
    Final Odometer Reading: 17,340
    Best Fuel Economy: 29.5 mpg
    Worst Fuel Economy: 17.2 mpg
    Average Fuel Economy: 23.1 mpg
    Total Body Repair Costs: $175
    Total Routine Maintenance Costs (over 12 months): $85.84
    Additional Maintenance Costs: None
    Warranty Repairs: 1
    Non-Warranty Repairs: None
    Scheduled Dealer Visits: 2
    Unscheduled Dealer Visits: None
    Days Out of Service: None
    Breakdowns Stranding Driver: None

    Changes to the Spectra5 since 2005
    Cruise control is now standard in the Spectra5. The optional four-speed automatic transmission has been redesigned this year for greater durability and smoothness (although models with SULEV emissions still use last year's unit).

    Ups and Downs
    Ups: Abundant low-end torque, relatively roomy backseat, ample interior storage space for its class, easy-to-use stereo controls, nimble handling on curves.

    Downs: Engine is loud and somewhat lacking at high speeds, cabin is dogged by hard plastic, annoying buzzes and rattles, low front spoiler is a magnet for scratches.

    The Bottom Line: The Spectra5 is a great bet for those seeking a budget compact with outstanding interior room and utility. But if you're looking for class-leading handling, consider the Mazda 3 or Ford Focus ZX5.

    Recalls and Problem History
    Recalls:
    Airbags: Certain vehicles were found to have a problem with the airbag's Occupant Classification System (OCS) that could lead to infants in child restraint seats being classified as adults. The problem was corrected by reprogramming the vehicle's OCS electronic control unit.

    Problem History:
    We noticed occasional buzzes and rattles coming from the Spectra5's sunroof and headliner. The dealership was unable to duplicate the problem, so the issue was not corrected.

    Dealer Service Reviews
    Worthington Kia in Long Beach, California
    July 2005
    We took the Spectra5 in for an oil change and tire rotation. Service was satisfactory.

    Kia of Long Beach in Long Beach, California
    January 2006
    We took the Spectra5 in for an oil change and tire rotation; to address an open recall; and to investigate buzzes and rattles that occasionally emanated from the sunroof and headliner. Service was satisfactory.

    What Consumers Say
    "Trust Edmunds, I did. Good things from Kia do come in blue packages. Engine is smooth and pulls well in normal driving. Seats are very comfortable; finding a comfortable driving position was a snap. All of the controls are within easy reach and the buttons are intuitive. Handling is very good; it handles bumps and ruts in the road nicely. It's a great commuter. The radio/CD is not as bad as the reviews seem. Just don't try to thump the bass too loud. Getting 30-32 mpg. I'm having a blast driving the car and my son's friends think it's 'cool' to boot. Not bad for less than $15K!" — 004TJK, January 20, 2006.

    "Got rid of my Ford lemon and looked around. Was turned off by rude salesmen at Honda and went to Kia. Took the car for a test-drive, loved it and bought it. Got a great deal. It gets better every week. Rides great and the gas mileage is above average. I recommend it highly (my kids think it's cool!)."
    Mike, December 12, 2005.

    "I bought my Spectra wagon because they were having a sales drive here in Dallas. The car was far more than I expected. The fit and finish were flawless and the attention to detail in assembly was very good (none of the electrical was taped, but encased in tubing). I drive 80 miles to and from work 6 days a week and the car is fun and comfortable to drive. The ergonomics are good (I weigh 240 pounds and am 5' 8" tall and the car fits me just fine). All and all, I am very pleased with my purchase!"
    John, November 29, 2005.

    "I've had my Spectra5 for one month and continue to be impressed with it. I have not had one issue thus far. Whether in the city, on the highway or even on a gravel road, the car is comfortable and much fun to drive. It handles extremely well and the sport suspension is great. So much bang for the buck, it's surprising that there aren't more of them on the road."
    Sandra W, July 28, 2005.

    Sort By:

    mike449 says:

    09:13 AM, 01/17/2010

    had my 2005 spectra 5 since new every year the ac has to be charged (since new) and now it costs me. the front spoiler is held on with doublesided tape which comes loose every winter. parts are very hard to get. bought touchup paint from kia but it does not match at all. the doors have a awful wind noise that developed after a year, but only in a certain crosswind. dust blows in from under the floor in the rear. the front passenger seat is only good for short trips as it causes back aches. a true rating of a car should be done at 50,000 miles (pay attention here you worthless car critics) not new ones. thats when a true review can be done. this is a shame as I bought a rio in 2002 that was a great car for 100,000 miles with no problem. this will be my last kia

    Sort By:

    Close

    Share on Facebook Share on Facebook
    Share on Twitter Share on Twitter

    Advertisement

    Tags

    Advertisement