"How do I get your job?"
It's the second-most-asked question every automotive journalist gets, right after, "What's your favorite car?" And, well, the truth is, there are an infinite number of ways to break into the automotive-writing culture.
There are people who wander into the car-writing business because their neighbor happened to be someone who knew someone. Others were hired as temps and wound up test drivers. And some were born into it since Dad was the editor in chief of Popular Mechanics. Then there are those who pursued their career with laserlike focus, relentless drive and some far-fetched (and effective) creative effort.
Any Opening Anywhere
There's no right way, no wrong way and no single way to get into the business of writing about cars. But you need to know the business and the culture that surrounds it to find a way in.
"I went to the University of Michigan because it was in Ann Arbor and I wanted to work for Car and Driver or Automobile," explains Eddie Alterman who became the editor in chief of Car and Driver and Caranddriver.com last year. "I went there to get a gofer job and did that at Automobile during my college career. The summer that I graduated, [Automobile's founder and former Car and Driver editor] David E. Davis Jr. was moving and I helped them move from their house. We got friendly and he hired me full-time."
Former Popular Mechanics automotive editor Ben Stewart got his start by meeting magazine staffers at 4WD-truck shows. "My truck wasn't worth featuring in a magazine," says Stewart, "but I knew where they were going to be shooting features and I asked if I could tag along. That's how I met [journalist] Tom Morr. And eventually that led me to a job at Four Wheeler. I even wrote a feature about my own truck."
David Freiburger — editor in chief of Hot Rod Magazine, Hot Rod Deluxe, HotRod.com and Hot Rod TV — began writing freelance stories while he was working in the automotive aftermarket and meeting journalists. Scott Oldham, the editor in chief of Edmunds.com and Inside Line, began by toting former CSK Publishing polyglot editor Cliff Gromer's camera bag around at car shows. I self-published a parody of Car and Driver and sent it to every car magazine in the country.
No matter which channel each of us found, what we have in common is meeting people already established in the business. And once they've been met, we somehow convinced them we could solve their problems. It's a trick that works every time.
Brains vs. Education
In sum, your education may or may not matter much.
Eddie Alterman has a degree in English, while David Freiburger spent a few haphazard weeks at Cal State Los Angeles and then dumped that for successive jobs at Burbank Dodge and the Glendale Speed Center. Former Car and Driver Editor in Chief Csaba Csere has an engineering degree from MIT. I have a degree in political science from UC Santa Barbara. Scott Oldham attended the New Jersey State School of Therapeutic Barbering.
To really be successful, you can't afford to be anything less than your own worst critic.
Your brain and your skills, however, matter a lot.
"It's a very strange combination of skills," reveals Alterman. "It's right brain and left brain. You need a real knowledge of how cars work and you have to be able to communicate it. You need to drive well and you need to know the history of cars. Some of that you only get from experience. It's a schizophrenic skill set."
"It's such an intricate matrix of stuff," David Freiburger notes. "You need to write, shoot photos and market. You need an enthusiast background to sell the 'cool' to the audience."
Of course, the proliferation of Web sites means anyone can become a "published" journalist. And it's easy to start your own blog with an essentially zero-dollar investment. But doing it doesn't necessarily mean doing it well.
"There are probably more people out there writing about and photographing cars than ever before," adds Freiburger. "But it's questionable whether any of them are getting edited. There are a ton of people waiting to work here, but they're not remotely qualified. I don't care about a resumé; I care about clips. I'd rather see an unedited manuscript."
To get noticed, you have to develop a network of contacts. And to get those contacts, you need to put yourself out there. Send e-mails. Write fan mail. Look at what really makes up a publication or Web site and figure out what it is they need most; it's not Ferrari road tests.
A magazine like Hot Rod is always looking for well-written, cleanly photographed tech stories. Car and Driver needs all those small features at the front of the book. Inside Line needs immediate breaking news that's pertinent to its audience. Those are where you're most likely to break through, so start coming up with ideas. And write like your living depends on it.
It Really Is a Job
Believe it or not, automotive journalism is a real job.
Staff members of magazines and Web sites need to aggressively pursue stories where no one else is looking. They need to meet deadlines, even if it means working through the night. They need to want to write stories about cars not just because they're getting paid to do it, but because they love to do it and strive to do it well. Trust me, there's no worse agony than staring down a deadline knowing full well that what you've written so far completely sucks...at midnight.
To really be successful, you can't afford to be anything less than your own worst critic when it comes to the quality of your work. You need to be a strong writer who is committed to getting stronger. Find somebody who is a better writer than you and beg them to edit your copy. Just because you love every word of it, doesn't mean it's very good. And every good writer was taught by a better writer.
You also need to be a good reporter who asks the right questions the right way. You need to know photography well enough so that you can put together a good visual presentation. And, nowadays, you need to be both familiar and comfortable with video and the Internet. Over time, anyone who doesn't have all that, washes out.
"Someone who comes in and is cocky and knows everything?" says Eddie Alterman. "That person is in for a rude awakening."
Sure, if you do it well, continue to listen and improve your skills, chances are you'll eventually get to drive all the cool cars. Or build some mighty hot rods. And you'll get to go to places you never even dreamed of visiting. But that's not what the job is about. It's about being good at a defined list of skill sets like any other job. And wanting to visit the Ferrari factory because it would be cool is not on the list.
"I find the younger people think the job owes them and not that they owe the job," reveals the not-that-ancient Freiburger. "They're there to get the rewards. And most of the time, it's the work that's the reward."
"I love the craft of creating content," asserts Alterman. "It's about words and pictures and putting them together. It's about making sure our voice is strong."
"I just want to go home at night thinking that what I did that day didn't suck," summarizes Scott Oldham. "Once in a while, it actually happens."
Get Writing
Skills are everything and the only way to get them is to work at it.
All good writers are first great readers. If you don't know what makes Dickens, Hemingway, Shakespeare, Twain and Stephen King great writers, you'll never get any better yourself. So take courses, download everything onto your iPad, and read all the greats until your retinas burn.
Then go to the library and pull up some back issues of car magazines. Read everything Brock Yates wrote for Car and Driver in 1970 and learn how to put the reader in the driver seat. Read Gray Baskerville's stuff in Hot Rod from the '80s and '90s and figure out what it means to have a distinctive voice and true enthusiasm. Read the real writers of today, guys like Peter Egan, Dan Neil, John Phillips III and Don Sherman. Google Tom McCahill, Ken Purdy and LJK Setright.
Keep informed about popular culture, history, politics and art. Good writing needs solid references and you can only mention Vanishing Point and Smokey and the Bandit so many times.
And if you don't own a quality digital SLR camera, get one and start shooting. Take a photo class if you must, but learn composition and lighting. Pay attention to the photo credits in magazines and Web sites, and you'll see that the same names appear over and over on the best stuff. There's a reason for that.
But most of all, write. Take every writing course you can and be grateful for any teacher who will care enough to point out exactly why your writing is crap. If you're in school, slave away on the school paper. If there's a newsletter where you work, volunteer to write it. Start your own blog, keep a diary, write about every car you brush up against. Then rewrite everything you've written until it glistens with brilliance.
How do you do that? Here are three quick tips: Assassinate all the unnecessary words; lay off the exclamation points; and if you think you've read that lead before somewhere else, delete it and start over.
Then, when you have the skills, and the opportunity arises, you'll be able to take advantage of it. You never know when that opportunity is coming.
So get ready. And get going.

Add A Comment »
justjoshinya says:
05:35 PM, 09/07/2011
In all honesty I think that any advice one gives on this matter should be noted but also taken with a grain of salt. A lot of car critics of today are too focused on fancy words and its making them all seem the same when you read them. Take an issue of Automobile today vs 10 years ago and the personality of each critic was different, unlike today where they seem the same. Also it seems that we are too afraid of stepping on toes. Everyone seems to be stepping around quality issues such as too much plastics, ride quality, price etc. I am not sure if its because they are being paid by the car companies that they are reviewing or what. People read these reviews to get the facts about automobiles, and it can really help their decisions making of buying a specific make and model if they get the whole truth, and not just the information people (companies) want to hear. Plus auto makers read what people say about their cars and take their words into consideration for future models. Which helps out the consumers (us). I honestly would love to get into auto journalism. I obviously would need some work like most people who want this job. But we should all want to do this job with passion first, and think about the job later. From what ive seen in my short lifetime, its the writer with passion and love for these cars that writes the best reviews, and it seperates him/her from the run of the mill critic.
Lets grow some balls, and do this the right way. :)
zr1man says:
10:27 PM, 03/02/2011
I would think one of the first items in becoming a successful auto journalist is to have credibility and to tell the truth. This leads to respect and relevance in your opinions. After reading some of the reviews by inside line, I don't think they make the cut. Their reviews are slanted to who every is paying the most advertising dollars. These people are just not creditable. They continually slant their reviews in favor of the biggest ad dollar clients.
So build respect and report honestly. Oh, must love cars too!
v8vader says:
12:14 AM, 02/22/2011
lol cue the impromptu, unsubstantiated resumes in comment form
jays83gsl says:
12:44 PM, 02/21/2011
Honestly, for the last year I've been looking at getting into journalism, especially automotive journalism.
I realise there's a HUGE factor of 'knowing that guy' and I'm severely lacking in that factor. I know I'll just have to keep pecking at it and hope to knock a chip off the old block, so I can find that 'elusive connect.'
My writing style isn't the best, but I've looked at a few long posts here, with people claiming they'd be great journalists, and gag. The structure is terrible, there's no line breaks, the grammar is equal to that of a three year old Kiwi.
Sure, they have degrees and experience, and probably a good amount of passion, but I, myself, would ask what those degrees and experience have done for them.
In your article, you mentioned Czere, who is the very journalist that led me away from C/D and toward Edmunds with his terrible, soulless writing style, and wallet padded opinions.
I would love nothing more than to write for Edmunds, Car and Driver, or Road and Track, but I'm also smart enough to realise that, without a good location or money to buy better photography equipment, it's a pipe dream.
Until then, I'll be taking my $70 Samsung out and taking pictures of cars I test drive, while telling the dealer that it's for a local car magazine they've never been able to find.
mchspd1 says:
11:57 AM, 02/21/2011
Nice article! Thanks for the pics of the beautiful Pontiac G8 GXP!
atoomey212 says:
10:54 AM, 02/08/2011
Thank you IL for posting this article. I'm actually in sales, but being an automotive journalist is something I have always wanted to sink my teeth into. Maybe in a few years I will get into it somehow. I have been reading Car and Driver, Automobile and R&T since I knew how to read, and I have been passionate about automobiles my whole life. As an avid reader I think a lot of problems in automotive journalism to date, are the lack of knowledge and passion in cars. Im not talking about the writers ability to explain a limited slip diff, or perhaps the computer sequence for a traction control system to operate properly. I am talking about the knowledge of the individual brand, how the model being tested carries the bloodline of the brand into a new design. There are too many useless facts and not enough pragmatic advice that REAL buyers can benefit from. Cars are designed to appeal to a certain group of people, who are those people and WHY!? When comparing two different minivans, why would a certain family benefit from buying one than the other, and vice versa. For every comparison test, there are a group of cars, and for each ones upsides, there is a downfall that maybe one of the other vehicles triumphs in. There should NEVER be any emphasis on which one is more powerful, and which one handles better because from a realistic buyer's standpoint, that plain doesn't matter. I also read a recent test on an SUV comparison (Car and Driver), and the Land Rover LR4, the best in class SUV that achieves everything an SUV is purchased for and more, came in second to last place simply because of on road performance. If this test were done with emphasis on the purpose and versatility of what an SUV is built for, the BMW and Audi would come in last place, whereas they came in first and second. For lack of better words, MOST of these tests achieve USELESS facts and descriptions of opinions that are skewed so they can focus on the same thing OVER and OVER, and that is how fast it goes, how well it corners, blah blah. As a reader, that would be my advice to any aspiring writer; think about what your testing, its purpose, the market who will be potentially purchasing the vehicle, THEN analyze, examine and test!
mrnosy says:
04:18 PM, 06/07/2010
Hot Rod is the automotive magazine equivalent to being Amish. Big-block Chevelle makover,'67 Mustang-Bust Out Big Ponies from 351 small block ,Hemi Mopar Madness.Repeat.Forever.
epbrown says:
11:37 PM, 05/28/2010
Nice article. It's great that you guys stress good writing. I read almost none of the US car magazines because the writing tends to be, well, awful. To me, the UK magazines Car and Evo are what car writing should aspire to , though Automobile magazine often comes close.
However, the truth is most Americans don't care about writing enough for it to bother them.
pjstrifas says:
04:16 PM, 05/28/2010
Thank you for the encouraging article. I've been blogging for the past 14 months and have had some success (published on mainstream automotive sites). There are many opportunities beyond just the 'major' magazines and online sites to learn the craft and hone those skills.
Some things I've learned to do:
- write something every day
- impress your views on current events (editorialize)
- do a review of YOUR car (your friend's car, your mom's car etc)
- take pictures just to learn to take pictures!
- network --> find local cruise spots, join some auto clubs, read online forums
When you get to the point that you wake up every day anxious to write the next story or shoot the next vehicle with your DSLR -- then you're ready!
cocojoe53 says:
11:44 AM, 05/28/2010
The problem is honest, critical, evaluation of cars is subject to the writer not being to critical of the people paying the bills. It's not unlike movie reviews. With that said, I think Edmonds does a fine job at at least giving balanced reviews. I will never forgive Motor Trend giving Chevy Vega "Car Of The Year" in 1972.