Why We Bought ItHow It DroveInside the CabinSumming UpChanges to the Dodge Magnum Since 2005Ups and DownsRecalls and Problem HistoryDealer Service ReviewsWhat Consumers SayWhy We Bought ItIt's been our editorial policy to add each year's Edmunds' Most Wanted award winner to our long-term fleet, but for
2005 we modified the rule slightly.
Although there was no shortage of affection for the victorious
2005 Chrysler 300 sedan, the allure of spending a year with the 300's wagon twin, the Dodge Magnum, was too strong to ignore. With its tapered roofline, low greenhouse and aggressive grille, the Magnum isn't your mother's old wood-paneled Country Squire. Add the availability of Hemi V8 power and a performance suspension, and this wagon is today's equivalent of an old Mopar muscle car.
After reviewing the available trim levels, we chose a top-of-the-line RT, complete with a 5.7-liter, 340-horse Hemi V8 and standard rear-wheel drive. Although the RT already comes nicely equipped with leather seating, powerful Boston Acoustics audio, 18-inch wheels and stability control, our long-termer also boasted several additional feature packages. Side curtain airbags, a trip computer, steering wheel-mounted audio controls, dual-zone climate control, power-adjustable pedals, heated/power front seats, Sirius Satellite Radio and a UConnect hands-free communication system were among the notable goodies.
With such a compelling new vehicle in our grasp, the fight for seat time launched the Edmunds' editors into a full-on frenzy.
How It DroveAfter conducting a battery of instrumented performance tests, our team congratulated each other on making the wise decision to acquire the cool new wagon.
A quarter-mile time of 14.4 seconds brought smiles to our track-dusted faces, and over the next 11 months, the Hemi compliments dominated the Magnum RT's logbook: "The 5.7-liter Hemi V8 is a work of genius. It's perfectly happy tooling about all day just off idle, but when you nudge into the throttle, you get a heroic surge of pure power accompanied by a full-on king-of-the-jungle roar from the exhaust."
Not only was the Hemi fast, miraculously it wasn't the gas-guzzling beast we feared, as noted by
Inside Line's executive editor, Rich Homan: "On the long, straight, seemingly endless high-speed miles of Interstate 5, I never had a clue the Hemi's fuel-saving cylinder deactivation system was shutting down four of the engine's eight cylinders when cruising at steady speeds."
Inside Line Road Test Editor John DiPietro affirmed: "I took the Magnum down to San Diego, about a two-hour ride from L.A. With the Hemi's variable-displacement system that automatically shuts down half the cylinders under cruising conditions, I averaged about 20 mpg for the trip." Not a bad number for a 340-hp modern-day muscle car.
But Edmunds.com Editor in Chief Karl Brauer felt the Magnum offered more than just a big V8. He also praised the big wagon's ability to drive light on its feet: "In terms of handling dynamics, the Magnum feels like a premium German sedan, which is probably its biggest advantage over the competition. The Mercedes' underpinnings come shining through, taking the form of intuitive steering feel, high-speed stability, confident handling and compliant ride quality."
In a year's worth of praise, complaints were few. Minor drawbacks included steering that a few staffers consider to be "too light" while others mentioned not-so-great rear visibility, a drawback of the bunkered greenhouse. A wide turning radius could also be troublesome while navigating parking lots. But once out on the open road, these criticisms receded to the back of the mind.
Inside the CabinCountless thumbs-up were issued for the Magnum's hip exterior, but as the miles ticked by, it was the Dodge's modern, functional cabin that drew praise. "I had always been drawn to the Magnum's sinister high-beltline shape, but what's so satisfying is how the rest of the package follows suit," noted Rich. "The interior is smartly designed, the seats are ideally firm for a long drive and the outward vision is deceptively expansive in all directions — you'd never guess to look at it from the outside."
Interior plastics, silver trim pieces, and leather seat covers continued to look fresh, and throughout the months we also discovered that our Dodge Magnum RT was packed with little features usually found on luxury-branded cars. There's the one-touch lane-change feature that automatically blinks the indicators three times with one tap of the stalk, a power passenger's seat and rear-seat vents. Admittedly, these are little things but they add up to the feeling that DaimlerChrysler has gone the extra mile with this car.
Drivers raved about the Magnum's cavernous 72 cubic feet of cargo capacity, which transported everything from furniture to large, family pets. By folding down just the "40" part of the 60/40-split second-row seat, Brauer was able to transport a new desk plus his family of four home from an antique store, albeit with the help of some wire to hold the hatch down. Editorial Director Kevin Smith folded the entire rear seat flat and loaded a pair of golden retrievers comfortably in the cargo hold before heading north to join the rest of the Smith family for a little mid-summer R & R.
Once we discovered the ultraconvenience of the Magnum's UConnect system, which is essentially Bluetooth integration for your cell phone, we couldn't live without it. When you're in the car, simply leave your phone on, then you can make and receive calls through the car's hands-free system. All prompts are voice-activated and you only have to physically touch a button once during the whole process. For cell phone devotees, UConnect is truly a must-have feature.
Summing UpDuring it's year, the Magnum suffered just one mechanical issue which slightly colored its last few months in our garage. A reoccurring noise from the wagon's rear end sent us to the dealer on three separate occasions looking for a fix. A warranty repair was made during each visit, but twice the rattle and eventually a loud clunk resumed. Fortunately, the third time was the charm, and a repair to the bent exhaust system finally did the trick in the last month of the test, allowing us to heartily embrace the Magnum on the day of its departure.
Still, the last couple of months of minor issues hardly stifled our overall enthusiasm for the Magnum, and it remained until the end a solid favorite. Perhaps Kevin Smith summed it up best when he noted, "The Magnum is fast, flexible and friendly with plenty of character." A wagon with character? Who would've thought?
True Market Value at service end: $24,928
Depreciation: $8,117 or 25% of original paid price
Final Odometer Reading: 20,655
Best Fuel Economy: 23.7 mpg
Worst Fuel Economy:11.4 mpg
Average Fuel Economy: 17.3 mpg
Total Body Repair Costs: $59.95 (windshield repair)
Total Routine Maintenance Costs (over 12 months): $62.41
Additional Maintenance Costs: None
Warranty Repairs: 3
Non-Warranty Repairs: 1
Scheduled Dealer Visits: 2
Unscheduled Dealer Visits: 3
Days Out of Service: 3
Breakdowns Stranding Driver: 0
Changes to the Dodge Magnum Since 20052006 The Magnum receives bright trim on the SXT's grille, doors and interior. The SXT now comes with standard foglights, and both the SXT and RT now have an optional rear-seat DVD player that flips up from the center console. Eighteen-inch wheels are now optional on the SXT and 17-inch machined aluminum wheels are offered on rear-wheel-drive versions. Later in the model year, the SXT's four-speed automatic transmission will be replaced with a five-speed unit.
Ups and DownsUps: There's nothing like the Magnum's Hemi power; cool, retro styling; and roomy, comfortable interior.
Downs: The reoccurring rattle from the Magnum's rear became a downer as the months rolled along.
The Bottom Line: The Dodge Magnum is a wagon you actually want to drive.
Recalls and Problem HistoryRecalls: None
Problem History: - Rattle coming from the rear of the car. Dealer said the left-rear shock was bad and it was replaced.
- Rattle coming from the rear of the car. Dealer said the rear-seat latch was loose and made an adjustment.
- Clunk coming from the rear of the car. Dealer said a clamp holding the exhaust pipe was bent and it was hitting the body.
|
Dealer Service ReviewsBuerge Chrysler-Jeep in Santa Monica, CaliforniaMarch 20057,500-mile oil and filter change plus a tire rotation. Dealer overcharged us $7 and said they would issue a credit toward our next service.
June 200512,000-mile service which included an oil change, tire rotation and a few inspections. We asked the service advisor to do just this, and they went ahead and performed the more expensive dealer-recommended service instead, which included an unnecessary automatic transmission flush. We didn't immediately notice the error when we picked up the car, and this resulted in a messy situation in which we had to insist that they refund the extra charges to our credit card. This isn't the first time Buerge has tried to pull such a ruse, but the dealership's convenient location has kept us coming back.
Cerritos Dodge in Cerritos, CaliforniaApril 2005Disappointed with Buerge, we tried a new dealer to remedy the annoying rattle in the Magnum's rear. The dealer said we had a bad rear shock, ordered the new unit and replaced it two weeks later. Service was much improved compared to Buerge.
June 2005The annoying rattle returned. This time, they adjusted a rear-seat latch while we waited. All was quiet again for a couple of months.
October 2005The rattle has become a clunking noise. This time, service advisor Daniel Jacobo found the bent exhaust system was hitting against the body when the car went over bumps. It, too, was replaced under warranty.
What Consumers Say"I keep hearing so many bad stories about the Magnum RT to date. I have had a great experience. I've had it for 5 months and a little under 5,000 miles. Yes, I don't drive it every day to work. It's mostly a weekend and holiday car with my wife using it as needed to haul the kids around. So far, no complaints.
It is a great car, with the feel of a luxury Benz to it. If problems develop in the future, I will rely on my dealership along with my extended warranty to deal with the problem.
The ESP program, very roomy interior, the Hemi, GPS system, and the quiet ride are my favorite things. My only suggestion would be to see if you could put in a CVT transmission. I think that is where cars are headed for in the future as a standard." —
vdogrt, October 30, 2005"
Within 140 miles of use, a serious transmission problem was discovered. Also, the cooling fan clicks on and off way too often to be normal. And the factory tint on the windows is not removable, making it impossible to change the tint on the windows aft of the front-passenger windows. Steering wheel-mounted audio controls, GPS system and other technical gadgets are my favorite things. I disliked the recall for all transmissions containing the faulty O-ring.
Would like better quality on carpet and dashboard materials, and no factory-installed tinting on windows." —
Jaylinb, October 1, 2005"Great car. I wanted a fast car with lots of space, modern technology and comforts.
It was a choice between the Magnum, Audi wagon or Bimmer wagon. I'm very happy with the choice, but haven't been able to get 17 mpg no matter how I drive it. Steering wheel controls, nav, V8 are my favorite things. Please cut the throttle response time, and add bigger mirrors to improve visibility." —
lateif, September 30, 2005"
I bought my car sight unseen, never even test-drove it. What a chance I took, but there hasn't been one thing about this car that I am disappointed in! I love everything about my car except where and how the cruise control lever is located. I also own a C-5 Vette and I can honestly say I usually choose to drive the Magnum over it. I never thought I'd say that about any other car.
The Hemi does justice to its name. It's got the looks, the comfort, and the power I look for in a car. Just don't expect it to get very good gas mileage, but I knew that was the price to pay for pure happiness whenever I get behind the wheel. It is one of the roomiest and comfortable vehicles I've owned. Plenty of storage.
Love the interior, both in looks and comfort. Very roomy seats. Love all the nooks and storage compartments in hatchback. Plenty of legroom in front and backseats. Exterior is awesome to look at. Change the location and design of the cruise control. It's hard to reach behind the steering wheel & wiper/turn signal." —
I. lyons, September 7, 2005"
I had this car for four days before the engine blew (200 miles on it!). I was convinced that it was a lemon, but the dealership said it was a problem with the car and would not be covered by warranty. I'll take their word and assume it is an awful car. And DaimlerChrysler has backed the dealership!
Beware, if you buy this car (or the 300, Charger, or any other car with the same platform) and you have problems, they will not take responsibility. I had heard similar things but wanted this car so badly, I took a chance on it anyway. Biggest mistake of my life. I am actually left hoping that the engine problems continue so I can take them to task and claim it as a lemon. I am a VERY angry consumer!
Take responsibility for your incompetence!! I will never buy a Dodge, Chrysler, or Jeep again." —
Robert in Atlanta, August 8, 2005
Add A Comment »